When I was asked to preview the new concert DVD from Avril Lavigne I didn’t
know if I was the right person for the job. After all I’m not exactly the target
audience for this very young woman’s music. I thought my teenaged daughter would
be better suited to the task. For me a concert recalls memories of the Grateful
Dead, Hot Tuna and Jimi Hendrix. But, after some consideration I put the disc in
the player and decided to at least try to keep an open mind. I have to admit I
was pleasantly surprised. Now I’ve seen in passing parts of concerts on HBO with
the modern pop princesses like ‘Brittany’ and ‘Christiana’. They are a far
departure from the concerts I remember with overly elaborate special effects,
pyrotechnics and more costume changes than fashion week here in New York City. I
was actually delighted to see that Ms Lavigne has turned her back on this
growing trend and has returned a concert event to a simple interaction between
the musicians and the audience. This little slip of a girl stands before her
audience dressed not in inappropriate scantily clad costumes but in a regular
tee shirt and jeans, like a teenager that just got home from school. The stage
has little more than her back up band and herself, nothing to detract from the
purpose of a concert, to hear the music. Rather than being in a spectacular you
get a far more intimate feeling, you can actually relate to the performer, what
a concept. It is a performance that is devoted to the music. I sincerely hope
the young audience in attendance appreciates the rare find this is.
Ms Lavigne has talent. That much is certain. She can actually carry a song
with commitment and feeling. While a lot of her music is not particularly in
line with my personal taste I can appreciate a well constructed song and
performance when I hear one. The concert was recorded at her Buffalo New York
performance and includes most of her growing set list of hits. Her music runs
the gamut from the hyper-energetic ‘Sk8er-Boi’ (Can’t these kids learn to spell?
Oops, my age is showing.) and ‘Complicated’ to the haunting ballad "I’m With
You". With the faster songs Ms Lavigne literally bounces up and down, across the
stage. She commits completely to her performance and the audience responds
wildly. Her true talent shows in the more emotional slower songs. Here she
demonstrates that she can truly sing. While her range is not as incredible as
many current performers it is more than enough for the music she has chosen. Her
tonal control is far beyond her years and emotionally involves her listeners. As
an aside I have to note that when she belts out a song she has one of the
largest, square shaped mouths since Fairuza Balk. She just opens wide and lets
the song form a tidal wave that flows over the audience.
Okay, I have to go into parent mode for a moment. I did object to the many
images of Ms Lavigne drinking and obviously drunk. In the documentary of the
tour seems to rarely be without a beer in hand, not a very good presentation
considering the age of the target audience.
Ms Lavigne certainly can relate with her followers. Mostly the audience is
composed of young girls that apparently know the lyrics to each and every song
performed. Baggy clothes and loose fitting ties seem to be the outfit of choice
for her fans, emulating the causal fashion of this singer. Her performance comes
across as a young girl having fun, doing what she wants to do in life. There is
a feeling that she is singing from her life, albeit one that has not racked up a
whole lot of years. There is an undisputed energy that surrounds this performer.
I hope that success does not spoil what she has going for her. Her mater of
fact, in your face manner is not as off putting as it may sound. She
demonstrates a determination that carries over to her music. While not in the
league of the performers of my youth she is one of the better acts around today.
Fox has gone above and beyond for this DVD. The audio is a crisp, clear Dolby
5.1. The rear channels are mostly reverberation from the audience; the sub
woofer punctuates the bass line but does not overwhelm it. The stereo separation
is better than many of the concert discs I have heard. The full screen video
provides a well balanced color palette and very good contrast between light and
shadow. You get a good feeling of being at the concert. Aside from a full length
concert the disc sports a number of extras. There is a bonus CD that features
six songs including four previously unreleased titles. There is ‘Fuel’ mastered
from an MTV live performance, ‘Unwanted’, ‘Basket Case’ and ‘Sk8er Boi’ recorded
at a Dublin concert, ‘Knockin' on Heaven's Door’ recorded in Buffalo and ‘Why’,
the ‘B’ side of the UK release of ‘Complicated’. Even this little CD is well
mastered. The DVD extras include the music videos for "I'm With You", "SK8er Boi",
"Complicated", "Losing Grip", and "Knocking On Heaven's Door". There are also
behind the scenes footage of Ms Lavigne et al as well as some out takes to round
things out.
While older audiences may tend to overlook this DVD those who are in the
typical demographic and those with kids in that age group will enjoy this disc.
You get a lot for the price including a performance by a young, rising star of
the music world. I didn’t think it would happen but I enjoyed myself while
listening to it, just don’t tell my daughter.
Posted 10/03/03