Some topics are such that they cannot help but to
touch the hearts of those who listen to them. Film makers have understood this
for ages and many have capitalized on the fact to create movies that have great
emotional depth. Two of the themes that have proven to be the most powerful in
this regard are those about a poor child forced to over come insurmountable
odds. Another is one of the greatest human tragedies in history the Holocaust.
When you combine the two there is a potential for a great tale of human
resiliency and the triumph of the human spirit. Such a film is ‘The Boy In The
Striped Pajamas’. This is the kind of movie that shows that even in the midst of
the darkest chapter in history there can be hope. There are still those that
refute that the Holocaust ever existed. Perhaps it was just too large a horror
for them to get their minds around. I have had the honor of meeting several
people who have survived this inhuman time. What struck me most was the way they
embraced life finding joy in the smallest of things. They didn’t speak a lot
about the atrocities that they endured. Instead they related stories of how they
helped each other to survive and the close bonds of friendship that emerged from
their ordeal. If you have ever seen a flower growing between the cracks in the
sidewalk you have a visual representation of how they got through this time.
Life will find a way to prosper even under the most brutal environment. All of
this went through my mind as I sat there watching this film. When you hear that
it is about a little boy in a concentration camp you might thing that it has to
be depressing. It isn’t. This is a movie dedicate to those that lived and died
in those terrible camps. It is a story of optimism; the kind that can only come
out of the worse time imaginable. The film was distributed by the independent
film branch of Walt Disney Studios; Miramax. While Disney is well known for
family entertainment and this movie has a PG-13 rating parents should make it a
point to delay letting the youngest members of your family watch it. They will
not understand and should be allowed to keep their age of innocence before
having to have the conversation that would be required after this film. For
older children make sure you sit with them. This film needs to be fully
discussed as a family after watching it. It is vital that the next generation
knows about this darkest chapter of human history. The film is now available on
DVD and along with the extras it is one that deserves to be watched and receive
a spot on your shelves.
The film is based on the best selling novel of the
same name by John Boyne. Assuming the difficult task of transferring this story
from the page to the big screen fell to Mark Herman as well as the task of
directing it. This had to be a big change of pace for Herman since his previous
works had all been comedies of one sort or another. Perhaps this helped though.
It gave him the eyes to not specifically focus on the tragedy which kept the
movie from being a dry history lesson. At the center of the story are two eight
year old boys; Bruno (Asa Butterfield) and Shmuel (Jack Scanlon). Bruno is the
son of a high placed Nazi while Shmuel is Jewish boy behind the barbed wire that
demarks the nearby concentration camp. As far as Bruno can understand his new
friend wears stripped pajamas; the meager uniform assigned to prisoners. The
considerable heart of this story is a coming of age drama. At eight years of age
these boys are on the cusp of leaving childhood behind. They are in the middle
of a world war but that is something that the grownups talk about and has never
really intruded in their young lives. That is until Shmuel and his family were
taken into custody just because they were Jews. As the story progresses each of
the boys is forced to come to grips with the reality of their circumstances.
There is little difference about them yet one is free and the other is trapped
in the camp. All rational people would be quick to denounce war; it is brutal,
violent and destroys lives in a myriad of ways. As parents we try our best to
keep these harsh realities from our children but there comes a time when they
have to see what the world is really like. In this film we witness the loss of
innocence as Bruno and Shmuel discover the harsh realities of the conflict
around them.
In directing this movie Herman has a sense of style
that is amazing to watch. He contrasts the boys in a gentle way we watch as the
friendship grows between them; just two boys in worlds were there are not a lot
of people their age. Then reality begins to set in. Bruno comes to understand
why Shmuel is in those pajamas and behind the wire. The young boy hears that
people are being killed en masse in the stark buildings that the wire surrounds.
This slams home to his young mind when he begins to realize that his father Ralf
(David Thewlis) is the commander of the facility. He had thought that his father
got a nice promotion that enabled his family to move to a nice home in the
country. When the boys meet Shmuel is hungry. Bruno begins to bring him food and
they play checkers together. Herman juxtaposes normal childhood scenes like this
with the conditions of the camp and the indoctrination of Bruno. He and his
sister Gretel (Amber Beattie) are provided a State sanctioned tutor Herr Liszt
(Jim Norton) who teaches them using anti-Semitic Nazi propaganda as the basis of
their education. Bruno also begins to notice how poorly an elderly Jew in the
employ of his parents is treated. Life is confusing enough at this age but Bruno
and Shmuel are forced to grow up too fast.
The ending of this film is brutal in its reality. It
is also one of the things that will require parental guidance. This is an
important film to watch and understand but at times it is difficult to watch. We
all know that a story like this cannot have a traditional Hollywood happy ending
and the fact is it shouldn’t. Ultimately the film presents the story with taste
and style but the message is never sacrificed. The film is presented on DVD in
anamorphic 1.85:1 video with Dolby 5.1 audio. Both are done exceptionally well.
There is a commentary track by Herman and Boyne. They detail the problems in
making a film of such a difficult topic especially one requiring children in the
cast. This is expanded greatly with a making of featurette that heightens the
importance of the film. There are also a set of deleted scenes with optional
director’s commentary. It is best to keep that track on and let Herman explain
why the scene was filmed and finally rejected from the theatrical cut.