There is a certain fascination to a story that requires several novels to
unfold. Those tales that need maps and a lexicon to fully appreciate this
universal that came from a fertile and imaginative mind. J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle
Earth was one of the best of these. His fellow Oxford Don, C.S. Lewis also
endeavored to create such a place with his tales of Narnia. The first of these
books, The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe now is a
film and it was just a bit of bad timing that it came on the heels of the
incredibly constructed and financially successful Lord of the Rings. The story
opens in London during the almost daily blitz attacks by the Nazi Luftwaffe. The
times where arduous enough for adults but for the children it was
incomprehensible madness. The four children of the Pevensie family; Lucy (Georgie
Henley), Edmund (Skandar Keynes), Peter (William Moseley) and Susan (Anna
Popplewell) find themselves running from the bombings towards a shelter. Their
parents see that the city is no place for children and ship them off to the
countryside under the care of Professor Kirke (Jim Broadbent) and his very
proper housekeeper Mrs. MacReady (Elizabeth Hawthorne). While staving off the
endless hours of boredom the children play a game of hide and seek. The
youngest, Lucy, finds a stately old wardrobe, opens the door and hides. Pushing
past the coats she finds that she is no longer in the world of her birth but has
been transported to a forest in the deep of winter. There she meets Mr. Tumnus
(James McAvoy), who much to Lucy’s surprise is a faun, half man and half goat.
Tumnus explains that she is in the land of Narnia, a place where it is "always
winter and never Christmas." After awhile he takes Lucy to a place where she is
returned to her world.
While searching for Lucy as part of their game Edmund also discovers the
wardrobe but his experience is vastly different. He meets up with the White
Witch (Tilda Swinton) who extracts a promise from Edmund to bring his siblings
back through the wardrobe to Narnia. As it turns out the Witch is trying to
avoid the fulfillment of a prophecy that when four sons of Adam and daughters of
Eve come to Narnia the true king, Aslan (voiced by Liam Neeson), a majestic lion
who would return and bring truth, light and warmth back to the land. When the
four children return to Narnia they find that the humble home of Tumnus has been
destroyed and that Lucy’s half animal friend has been taken into custody by the
forces of the White Witch. Lost and confused the foursome is taken in from the
cold by a talking Beaver (voiced by Ray Winstone) and his amiable wife (Dawn
French). They tell the children about Aslan. All the children are amazed except
for Edmund who harbors an unexplainable dread. Father Christmas arrives to
provide gifts to the children. Peter receives a sword, Susan a bow, quiver of
arrows and a horn, and to Lucy a healing potion and dagger. From there the
children are swept into a classic conflict of good and evil, of trust and
betrayal.
It is nearly impossible not to contrast Narnia with Middle Earth, after all
both where written by Oxford Don, who just happened to be friends. The main
difference lies in the intent of the respective works. While Tolkien’s novels
where mostly pure entertainment Lewis was forwarding his on beliefs. He was a
devote Christian and his faith he woven throughout the story. As almost everyone
knows by know Aslan is a Christ figure. He sacrifices his life to pay the blood
debt incurred by a betrayal at the hand of Edmund. The Witch is pure evil, a
satanic force resolved to take all that is good from the world. This is good
versus evil with a Christian slant. The film version of the Ring trilogy is
targeted for an older audience than Narnia. This film has unmistakable Disney
touches that make talking animals natural and acceptable.
Keeping with the younger intended audience the main cast are mostly children.
Fortunately, the casting directors did their jobs well and came up with an
excellent group of young actors. Georgie Henley is a delight as young Lucy. She
comes across almost like a British version of Dakota Fanning, maturity and
professionalism beyond her tender years. She is someone the girls in the
audience can identify with and the parents will feel and overwhelming need to
protect. Skandar Keynes has one of the more difficult roles as Edmund. He has to
play between the natural innocence of a child with the betrayal so typical of
adults. He plays Edmund as a boy growing to manhood in a world torn apart by
war. When he enters Narnia he doesn’t see a fantasy world but more conflict and
war. William Moseley is the perfect handsome male lead. The young girls will
swoon and the boys will imagine themselves in his place. He portrays Peter as
the eldest sibling who knows that it is up to him to save the day. Anna
Popplewell is a talented as she is pretty. She gives a performance as Susan that
invokes images of a Celtic warrior princess. Popplewell provides the necessary
inner strength required to make her role believable. The performance by Tilda
Swinton is deliciously wicked. She is the perfect storybook witch in all her
evil glory.
This is the first film by director Andrew Adamson where he has to contend
with live action, his previous films where the animated Shrek flicks. Before
that he plied his craft as a special effects supervisor in such films as Toys
and two or the 90’s Batman flicks. This early work shows with Narnia. Instead of
the stark realism of that other epic set of films Narnia has an almost dreamlike
feel to it. That is not to say that there isn’t a sense of grandeur to the film.
It is set against a wonderfully detailed world that will amaze children
everywhere. For the adults there is too much of a ‘seen that before’ nature. The
battle scenes are riveting with the entire flourish we have come to expect.
Adamson paces the film well although some of the needed exposition has the
tendency to slow things down a lot. The computer graphics are seamlessly
incorporated and the live action has the ability to connect with the audience.
Disney/Buena Vista has let out all the stops in bringing this film to DVD.
Consistent with the modern trend there are three variations available, Pan &
Scan, widescreen and the two disc collector’s edition. Considering the two disc
version retails for about $7 more than the widescreen (I can’t recommend and P&S
version) you might as well go for it. The video is presented in a stunning
2.35:1 anamorphic transfer. The color palette and contrast are near reference
quality. The DTS six channel audio features one of the best and fullest sound
fields I’ve heard in a while. The commentary track features not only the
director but remarks by a group of children, a nice touch considering the target
audience. There is a blooper reel that is amusing as well as some ‘Narnia fun
facts’. The two disc set also has a lot of behind the scenes featurettes. There
is one that shows the creation of the numerous creatures and a segment detailing
the making of the melting river sequence. While more for the younger set this is
a film the whole family can watch and enjoy together.
Posted 3/18/06