There are many variations of the time honored buddy
flick. You know the ones; two men, two women, father and son and even mother and
daughter. You most likely have even seen a buddy flick of a boy and his dog.
What I have never seen before after watching literally hundreds of movies in the
genre is one about a man and his duck. I really can’t remember a lot of mallard
oriented films in the past. Of course there was ‘Howard the Duck’ but the less
said about the one, the better. Water fowl has never been the focus of stories
with the possible exception of a family dinner. The 2005 film ‘Duck’ by Nicole
Bettauer is now available on DVD through Westlake Media. It is an odd duck of a
movie, pun intended. At its heart is an unorthodox buddy movie but there are
strong overtones of a dystopian glimpse into the very near future. While the
slightly future society depicted has some science fiction elements to it this is
just the setting. The film is a strong character study albeit with an aquatic
avian opposite the leading man. The movie gives a good try but is riddled with
missteps along the way. It sways between the overly melodramatic and comical
keeping the audience wondering just what kind of flick they are watching. This
is one of those films that has potential but never quite gets there. Still, this
is what independent film is all about; taking chances. There is no way that a
major studio would have entertained the idea of a man and duck movie. It is also
refreshing that Bettauer took the high road with this film instead of doing what
so many of her male counterparts have done; the quick and cheap horror flick.
Even if the film is not as good as it could be you have to give credit to the
cast and crew for trying something novel. There is precious little originality
in the film industry and this movie is worth watching just because it is
different.
The film was written and directed by Nicole Bettauer.
This is here first screenplay and it does get an ‘A’ for effort. Previously she
has directed a short and a romantic comedy so it is good that her talents are
being focus in a way to broaden her artistic horizon. Not only is this a twist
on the classic buddy flick but it takes the road trip flick and turns it on its
head. Buddy movies and road trips have gone together since the thirties with
Hope and Crosby. Usually they are played for laughs but Bettauer tries to
instill a more serious side to the proceedings. Most dystopian movies are set
far enough in the future to allow for a back story of how the world came to
terrible shape depicted. She sets the tale in 2009, only four years from the
2005 release year. Most of what she shows going wrong in society is already
manifesting and are making current headlines. There is the collapse of Social
Security and the bankruptcy of pension plans as well as the overwhelming cost of
health care. This may be part of why a lot of people have less than a stellar
view of this film; it hits too close to home. The one great thing about a road
trip format is how it is conducive to a vignette oriented approach to the story
telling. Rather than have the situations come to the main characters they go to
them. This opens up the film to a series of short stories to highlight the main
themes. This allows for a mixture of humor with the darker plot device of a
country in collapse. It does manage to take a serious set of problems that we
face as a society and humanize it through the eyes of a lonely man and his duck.
This down turn in the government’s responsibilities to its citizens is
contrasted with how people in such a situation manage to survive; they refocus
their priorities and life in general. For Arthur (Philip Baker Hall) he is at
the end of his wits when a duck (Joey) imprints on him. Arthur has out lived his
wife and son as well as all his friends. His government has let him down and he
is about to commit suicide when the duck comes along. Just having this innocent
life dependant on him gives him a new and unexpected reason to life. He tries to
take to duck to his apartment but he is in arrears for the rent and they don’t
allow pets of any species. The unlikely pair are homeless and set out to find a
place that will suit them both so they can be happy. The script can get sappy at
times but this is Bettauer’s first script and it is certain her talent in this
arena will only grow as she moves forward. This screen play may fall short of
what it could have been but it is fresh and original and that matters a lot.
Bettauer does very well in the direction of this film.
She sets up the story rapidly with great economy getting right into the quirky
story. She is a very visual director letting the often bleak settings show the
plight of the country and its citizens. The sheer absurdity of a man and his
duck plays against the dismal world of the near future. Thankfully we do seem
off track from her vision in 2005. For one thing Jeb Bush will not be president
although a quick look at the newspaper’s headline will tell you we are on track
for the government cut backs on social programs and the general fall of the
economy. She is stretching things a bit even with a short running time of about
ninety minutes. The episodic nature of the movie does help out though. The story
does seem to be stretched out more than possible but overall the film works as a
heartwarming movie; a great way to take on such grave social issues. With all
the misery around him Arthur has found a unique way to go on with life. Many
facing retirement have concerns that after a lifetime of hard work there is
nothing left to the time remaining than poverty. This film shows one man finding
a way to not only survive but in his own way, thrive.
Hall is one of those actors who turn up in the most
unlikely films. This is most likely due to the range that this man has. He has
played broken men as he did in ‘Hard Eight’ to more flamboyant roles as in
‘Magnolia’. He has even made is mark as the Joe Friday like library cop in an
episode of Seinfeld. While this is not the best use of his abilities he brings
something special to the role. He imbibes it with a sense of humanity that helps
to carry the film. Joey the duck does well but then again all he has to do is
quack and waddle.
The DVD is released by Westlake Media and as always
they do a great job. The film is well mastered and the disc contains plenty of
extras including a commentary track that is fascinating. This is an odd flick
but one that shows incredible promise for the director and will peak your
interest.