Bestselling novels have proven to be a very fertile ground for movie
screenplay. After all the story has a proven track record with the public,
garnered a positive reputation and offers a chance for actors to interpret
characters that are already a known quantity to the perspective members of the
audience. In fact if the novel is sufficiently high profile then there will be a
targeted demographic already firmly in place, the down side is the fans of the
novel expect a literal translation of the beloved book brought to life on the
screen. Of course those typically prove to be unrealistic expectations going
into a viewing of the film. The differences in story telling methodology between
the written word and the visually driven motion picture is vast and many well
intended filmmakers have failed to properly make the transition. The alterations
in pacing, plot motivation, character development and necessity for dramatic
license often make this job untenable. Fortunately for the fans of Matthew Quick
and his widely popular novel ‘Silver Linings Playbook’ the migration to the
screen overseen by writer/director David O. Russell the results ate exceptional.
I don’t always manage to do so but in a few high profile cases I doo seek of the
original novel for my e-reader and devour it before I got an opportunity to
review the Blu-ray edition. As it turned out I was doubly rewarded in doing so;
first the book is excellent and second it reaffirmed my hopes that the film
would be able to expertly capture the tone and full emotional impact of the
novel. There is a valid reason why this movie was the darling of the award
season with an impressive six Academy Award nominations including Best Picture,
Best Direction and all four Acting categories with a win for Jenifer Lawrence
for Best Actress in a Leading Role.
After eight months of in-patient care in a mental health facility Pat
Solitano Jr. (Bradley Cooper) found himself back in the real world, released
from the therapeutic environment he had become accustomed to. He is not entirely
on his own being released to the custodianship of his parents. The diagnosis
that rationalized his interment was bi-polar disorder, and after several other
methods failed to produce the desired results a more secure environment was
deemed preferable. During his time inside Pat became close friends with an
incorrigible patient, Danny (Chris Tucker), whose constant stream of legal
actions directed towards the hospital. When Pat finally reenters the world he is
faced with several major changes. Among the first is the court mandated
continued therapy Dr. Cliff Patel (Anupam Kher), intended to ease Pat’s
transition into the less restricted environment outside the hospital walls,
In many ways having such a support system in place could prove to be
beneficial to Pat as he faces the serious changes in his personal world but that
would not be a simple matter to achieve. His previous job of high school teacher
had grounded him before his symptoms fully manifested. He came home from work
one day to find his wife Nikki (Brea Bee) taking a steamy shower with another
man. To make the situation more humiliating their wedding song was playing in
the background. His response was to administer a violently beating the man. Pat
remains resistant to pharmaceutical management of his symptoms. Upon his release
Pat discovers that his father Pat Sr. (Robert De Niro) has hit with the economic
down turn and loss his job. In order to make ends meet Dad has turned to
bookmaking in hope of gathering the capital required to open his own restaurant.
In and romantically themed story there has to be that tipping point moment
that serves to initiate forward emotional motive. In this case it happens
innocently when Pat accepts a dinner invitation with an old friend, Ronnie (John
Ortiz). Another dinner guest just happens to be Ronnie’s sister-in-law, Tiffany
(Jennifer Lawrence), a recently widowed young woman. Tiffany’s life is on a
downward spiral; besides losing her husband she recently lost her job. This
establishes a classic set of circumstances familiar to anyone that has gotten
into romance literature or movies; a pair of damaged people adrift in life after
undeserved misfortune has struck in full force. Tiffany finds herself in an
uncomfortable passion when Nikki is recruited as a go between passing letters
between Nikki seeking a reconciliation and Pat. Meanwhile Pat and Tiffany and
begun a friendship based on a compatible set of neuroses. This establishes the
requisite romantic triangle to create the dramatic tension necessary to propel
the character arcs.
What helps to differentiate the story from other examples of the genre and
provide an attraction for male viewers is the infusion of a football motif to
the mix. Looking for a quick boon in finances Pat Sr. asks his son to go to a
Philadelphia Eagles game with him. Considering his new vocation he was induced
by using his son as a ‘good luck charm’ to bet everything he has on the game.
Pat was supposed to go with Tiffany to her dance practice critical to her
involvement in an upcoming competition. Pat regrets accompanying his dad instead
of a beautiful woman when he becomes involved in a fight with some thugs; the
outing made worse when the Eagles lose the game.
The story manages to ideally balance two forms of competition; a sporting
event, football and a form of artistic expression, dance. Much of the appeal of
the film is generated by how well the differences and similarities between the
two forms of physical activity is handled. It provides a unique foundation to
build the character arcs and further the dilemmas they collectively face. This
had the effect of taking extremely familiar and overly used tropes into
something excitingly fresh. This is a romantic film that men and women can
embrace and enjoy equally; a rare and wonderful commodity in this usually
feminine oriented type of film. From a script vantage point Russell seems to
balance on that thin line between keeping true to the original themes and
emotional integrity while making the story his own. This is frequently done with
established classics in literature so it should not come as too much of a
surprise a talented filmmaker employed the techniques to a recent literary work.
His previous successes in combining screen writing and direction seamlessly into
expressing himself as a filmmaker include I Heart Huckabees’’,’ Flirting with
Disaster’ and his other dual Oscar nomination for writing, direction and
picture, ‘The Fighter’. This is a man whose considerable talents have been
sharpened by experience and working with the best material and performers on the
scene today. David O. Russell is one of the forces to reckon with in today’s
film industry,
It would be easy for Jennifer Lawrence to become type cast, as an extremely
beautiful young woman currently starring in one of film’s most popular action
franchises around, ‘The Hunger Games’. The thing is Lawrence went into that much
sought after role with an Academy Award Best Actress nomination. If you have
every watch her in interviews she possesses a natural charm that makes her seem
relatable; a quality that readily transfers over to her on screen performances.
With the support of a seasoned cast include Robert Di Niro this film is a treat
that will entertain no matter how many times you experience it.