Certain movies are long awaited and create a certain amount of discussion. Very near
the top of a list to this type of movie has to be Star Wars Episode One: The Phantom
Menace. This prequel of the original trilogy set records when released. It also seems to
have many divided as to its cinematic merits. Okay, anyone even remotely interested in
this disc knows the story. The Trade Federation has set up a blockage of the tiny planet,
Naboo. Set to resolve the dispute are a jedi master Qui-Gon Gin (Liam Neeson) and his
young apprentice Obi-Wan (Ewan McGregor). They hope to free the control of the planet to
its elected queen played by Natalie Portman. After a battle (of course) they run to the
planet of Tattooine where they meet a young human slave, Anakin Skywalker (Jake Lloyd). It
seems that young Skywalker is so strong in the force that he may be the one foretold that
will bring balance to it and help resolve the evil influence of the Sith Lords. As a
father of a teenage daughter I appreciated the role given to Ms Portman. While the young
queen was not afraid of getting into a gun battle now and then, she felt a deep commitment
to her people and used her wits to resolves the problems. There is fairly deep development
of many of the characters and their relationships. For example, there is love between the
boy and his mother. When Qui-Gon can only free one of them the mother sacrifices her
freedom to ensure a better life for her son. There is also some subtle highlighting of the
relationship between the jedi master and his apprentice. There is the respect of the
student coupled with the pride of a master about to see his young charge take a big step
towards becoming his peer. This is contrasted with the fear and desire for power that
holds the Sith apprentice to his master.
One thing George Lucas knows how to do is assemble an excellent cast for his modern
fables. While it would be difficult to recreate the chemistry of the original cast this
new cast holds together well and works it. Neeson is among the better actors out there
today. His range is incredible. From his role as a deaf mute in Suspect to his award
winning lead in Schindler's List this actors talent overflows his extremely tall frame. In
fact, many sets had to be extended because of his height and I felt sorry for the camera
man having to frame any scene with Neeson and Portman in it. As mentioned before the role
of the queen is one that serves as a role model for young girls. As such it requires an
actress that is seasoned, polished and intelligent. Ms Portman is perfect here. Her talent
in such films as Leon and Beautiful Girls has blown me away. She is an actress to watch.
McGregor adds a bit of lightheartedness to the film. He wears the role of the apprentice
well. He conveys a sense of enthusiasm and need for adventure that a young jedi should
have. There is also a balance with the respect and devotion he conveys towards his master.
George Lucas is one of the best directors around. Still, there are aspects of this film
that many have trouble with. Among the best know example is his digital character Jar-Jar.
While he does inject the required comic relief he is over played in most scenes. Lucas
knows how to cut CGI effects into his films but I miss the way he used to rely on the
actors more than the special effects team. His pacing here is perfect. The expository
scenes, necessary for act one of a trilogy, never bog down the film. After you learn what
you need to know there is always some great action scenes. One of the best is the famous
pod race. This is a direct homage to the race in Ben Hur. If you can, watch Ben Hur again
before seeing this film to see just how one famous scene can spawn another.
Now for the real details, the disc. The video was rather disappointing. There was a
noticeable grain to the transfer. It ranged from just below notice to interfering with
viewing many of the visual details of the film. With all the time and effort that went
into the visual effects for the film the transfer hardly did justice to the work these
people did. The color balance was excellent with little bleeding or shadow artifacts.
There are some glitches I could observe with the skin tones. Now, the sound, WOW! The
Dolby EX audio is nothing less than reference quality. Do yourself a favor and invite your
neighbors over when you watch this. If you dont you may find the police at your
door. This is a soundtrack that cries out for loud playing volume. The sound field draws
you in as very few films can. Even with all the sound effects that abound here the
dialogue can still be understood. The film disc has a commentary by Lucas and a niffty
little device of the required Star Wars opening roll up in what ever language you selected
for sub titles. The second disc is how an extras disc should be done. There are numerous
trailers, making of features, tone poems and a music video. There are also
some seven deleted scenes including the full pod race. For those interested in the how and
why of the special effects you will not be disappointed, there are a ton of behind the
scenes shorts for you to enjoy. Bottom line, you may hate Jar-Jar with a passion, you may
hate Lucas reluctance to release the rest of the series but dont let these
things deprive you of a great disc.