The cinematic arts are founded on its ability to transport the audience to
different times and places or transfix them with a new perspective on a familiar
setting. Occasionally the goal of the film is to be viewed as a work of art
providing the viewer with a beautifully crafted visual experience. What is
exceptionally rare is for a film to engage aspects for all of these criteria but
the film under review here managed to achieve this lofty goal; ‘Tanner Hall’.
First of all it should be noted that the film is by no means perfect but it is
obviously a creation borne from the passion and commitment of the filmmakers.
The movie demonstrates an abundance of heart, a degree of sensitivity blended
with raw, honestly portrayed emotion to more than carry the film. Sometimes a
film can leverage a few technical flaws into a means to better connect with the
audience. In the case with this movie a too highly polished film would severely
undermine the integrity of the piece. The primary theme explored here is the
transition of a group of girls on the cusp of adulthood. By its intrinsic nature
such a period is imperfect, wrought with hesitation, missteps and broad swings
in emotion. Under the standards that are generally applicable to movies erratic
pacing and wide fluctuations in the emotional foundation would be considered a
negative. With ‘Tanner Hall’ it comes across as a realistically painted return
to that time we all went through. My most of us may not have gone through this
time in an all girl boarding school the emotional impact will stir similar
memories held in common to all teens about to leave their childhood behind. This
is always a period of feelings reaching extremes and typically devoid of
moderation. This film captures this universal experience by filtering it through
circumstances that read as well understood by the filmmakers. This is a solid
example of juxtaposing what is novel to the audience founding it on experiences
we can all readily relate to. The icing on this treat is the expert use of
cinematography to reinforce the mood set so well by the story. The story will
hold your interest while the visual impact will captivate your imagination.
I realize that I might be in the minority with my opinion of this film but my
criteria for judging a film is whether relates its story successfully and if the
efforts of the filmmakers and cast representative of an honestly applied effort.
In both cases this film exceeds movies produced with similar circumstances. The
first thing that comes to mind when the term ‘girl’s boarding school’ is applied
is the requisite lesbian story line. Most of the time, particularly with male
filmmakers, the resulting direction will be the most hackney and exploitive way
possible. The team here responsible for the screenplay and direction Francesca
Gregorini and Tatiana von Furstenberg include such a relationship as part of the
character arc of one of the core group of student, Lucasta (Amy Ferguson). There
is nothing puerile in the treatment of the subject here although the way the
story arc progresses is admittedly awkward. While some may take issue with this
approach citing it as a negative I feel that it properly presents the internal
confusion in this young woman as she grapples with new and conflicting emotions
while discovering her sexual identify. Lucasta had always been viewed as a
‘Tomboy’ but once in university she is caught in a maelstrom of conflicting
feeling including a strong attraction to a fellow classmate.
The assignment of the archetype class structure is very predictable but
accurately reflects the composition of this kind of social setting. There is
Fernanda (Rooney Mara) who basically serves to provide the level headed point of
view to allow the story to unfold, sexualized Kate (Brie Larson) and the always
required mean girl Victoria (Georgia King). The foundation of the story is told
through Fernanda who has spent her career in Tanner Hall as the shy, reasonable
girl. Although not immune to the changes that will affect her entire group she
does make the best choice as the means to provide the story’s narrative. After
being familiar with each other for most of their childhood the girls are now in
their senior year, a tradition period of major life changes. Kate has set her
sights on choice male members of the faculty while Victoria manifest her
jealousy of Fernanda through wicked machinations to destroy her relationships.
Fernanda has developed a knotty relationship with Gio (Tom Everett Scott), an
older friend of her family which raises the ire and jealousy of Victoria.
The plot devices used to relate the story are over used but much of that is
because they are part of reality. Fernanda is from a family where her mother is
distant and emotionally unapproachable. Victoria’s nasty behavior towards her
classmates is just an external manifestation of her inner self hatred. She tried
to invoke some feeling by cutting herself in the shower. There is also the
mainstay of female teen angst movies including suicide and prescription
medication abuse. Admittedly this movie does have the trappings of a Lifetime
made for cable film albeit one with better than average production standards.
The thing is this is the freshman opus for this imaginative pair of filmmakers.
They are still exploring their craft and developing their style but definitely
on the correct tract. True to perennial advice they constructed this film from
their own experiences. The two have been lifelong friends who met at school.
This accounts who much of honesty that pervades this movie.
One bit of casting I just couldn’t comprehend was Amy Sedaris and Chris
Kattan as strangely horny faculty members. These two are better known as wacky
characters in comedy skits. Their user here is anachronistic and took me
completely out of the seriousness of the movie. I just don’t see why they were
included. I just don’t see what purpose they served in telling the story. The
other sides of the coin for casting are the young women portraying the leading
roles. They may be young but the each presents their work admirably. Mara is
from a successful acting family. Her sister Kate has a pivotal role in the
macabre television series ‘American Horror Story’ while Rooney is poised to take
on the coveted role of Lisbeth Salander, ‘The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo’ in
the upcoming David Fincher remake of the Swedish hit. This certainly will garner
well deserved attention to this interesting movie.